Coal causes controversy

This week the Woods under Threat team have been working on an open cast coal proposal – ‘exciting’ I hear you say, with a touch of sarcasm! And you would be right, parts of the application are immensely complex, the ‘geotechnical assessment’ is enough to discourage anyone from looking in more detail at the application. However at the same time the case is bizarrely intriguing and presents a key threat to ancient woodland.

The area put forward for the open cast is the Pentremawr colliery between Pont-henri and Pontyberem in Carmarthenshire, Wales. Historically coal mining was hugely important part of these communities and was responsible for the development of the villages. The seams of coal in the Gwendraeth Valley have been worked since the 1860s right up to mid 20th century, however the industry has now declined and is no longer so key to the area.

Recently an application was made to Carmarthenshire County Council from Draeth Developments Ltd to open cast the site. As you can imagine this has been met with horror by the local people, who have formed an action group to fight the proposals. There are too many examples across Wales of local communities being blighted by open cast coal for people not to be uneasy of any new open cast (Margam, Merthyr Tydfill to name a couple).

Extraction of coal has a huge impact. Photo: BGS (click to enlarge)

Extraction of coal has a huge impact. Photo: BGS (click to enlarge)

A few weeks ago a public meeting was held with a representative from Draeth Developments. In places the meeting was quite heated – it was fantastic to hear people sticking up for their local woodland and asking about the merits of an open cast coal mine when we are faced with such a threat from climate change. What was even more heart warming was people rightly questioning the merits of ‘replacing ancient woodland’ and asking how this is possible!

In response to the application we have lodged an objection with the County Council as we are hugely concerned over the impacts of the open cast mine on ancient woodland. Not only will there be a significant loss of ancient woodland but the ancient woodland that is not being removed by the proposals will end up right next door to a huge black pit. Definitely one of the ultimate ‘Neighbours from hell’.


About Alice Farr

Senior Campaigner - ancient woodland
This entry was posted in Climate Change, Woods Under Threat and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Coal causes controversy

  1. Pingback: The sun shines on Coed Hafodheulog again «

  2. Dear Sir or Madam,

    We register an absolute objection to this application.

    This is not sound environmental sense, will destroy ancient woodland which has a vital ecosystem and been with us since the Ice Age playing such an important part in the UK Biodiversity Action Plan and Climate Change. If you destroy any woodland (UK’s equivalent to rainforests) it will release so many tonnes of carbon just at the time when we have to reduce our CO2 by 80% by 2050. We’ve also reached a crucial point in trying to establish some action on reduction of CO2 to take to the Copenhagen Conference, so how on Earth and in all honesty and seriousness, can we claim to be reducing our CO2 output and trying to send the right message to all the other worlds’ leaders when we’re acting so irresponsibly?

    Coal is a well-known fossil fuel which will run out very soon, and this application is not sustainable whereas sun, wind and sea are sustainable, natural gifts given to us to make the best use for future energy resources.

    The final question: How on earth do you replace an ancient woodland overnight? This is by far, beyond the bounds of all credibility.

    We most strongly urge Carmarthenshire County Council to refuse this environmentally irresponsible application and give no right of appeal.

    Yours faithfully,
    Mrs. S. M. Lodge

Sorry, comments are closed as we have moved to a new site: https://www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/blogs/woodland-trust/

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s